Goose's Ban Appeal

Status
Not open for further replies.

TJR | Goose

Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2017
Messages
38
Points
8
Age
23
Location
United States of America

In-Game Name:
Corporal Pumpkin

SteamID: STEAM_0:1:47257587

Steam Profile Link: http://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561198054780903/

Date of ban?: Sunday, October Eight.

Staff member that banned you?: I was banned by King Rome, Otherwise known as Captain Fox of Shock.

Why were you banned?: My Ban specifies as follows; "Minge, Disrespect, FailRP"

Reason you feel you should be unbanned?: For this next Section of my thread, I will be using numbers to refer to my points of why I should be unbanned.


I will start with what happened prior to my ban, since most appeals seem to lack that type of information.
The map was the home venator, it was around 9:30 PM, and I was by the Armory. I was with a few people whom have a similar mindset as me, and tend to get "Rowdy" when there is nothing going on. Me and a fellow 327th Member had walked up towards the checkpoint, and made some jokes referring to a statement he made, saying that Shock do not allow for jokes to be made. We said a few jokes, the main punchline being us saying "OOC" every sentence. This may of gotten out of hand, but keep in mind shock did not reprimand us, or arrest us. We decided to go into a more private area, due to us not wanting to bother the shock further, well.. me at least. At this time, we had gathered a small crowd, and we went into the waiting room of the medbay. At this time, we started doing the OOC jokes again, remaining in private and not causing any harm. Keep in mind during this no Roleplay was going on, and I don't think the staff had a plan to have any roleplay, and because of this we were being non-serious. The ban Occured after I had pressed my kill bind by mistake, and I started laughing in mic. It ended with a ban appearing from Captain Rome, whom apparantly had heard our conversation. Keep in mind, I was no Warned, Arrested, Or even Kicked prior. Sure, maybe an Hour - a Day ban would be acceptable, but I was banned for TWO WEEKS, THREE DAYS, and SEVENTEEN HOURS. I find this unacceptable, as people who /MASS RDM/ have similar types of bans. After this happened, I remained calm, talked to my captain over steam, and got into a discord with Captain Rome. Before I could even attempt to defend myself, he accused me of various things, gave me no time to even respond, and when I could finally sputter out how long my ban was, he said
"Oh, it was two weeks? Good." as if he did not know how long he banned me for.. He literally admitted he just typed in random numbers for my ban, which is probably twenty times more immature than ANYTHING I did. Not to mention, the posse of players I was with, whom did virtually the SAME thing as me, got no punishment. No Warns, no Kicks, no Bans. That is what I call; "Selective Administration." I'm not saying the people I was with should of been punished, I don't think thats fair to them. What i'm saying is I find it extremely immature of the staff member who banned me, and i'm quite frankly disgusted by the fact I was banned, let alone without any previous or prior warnings.

To put this into more simplified terms;
1. The Ban length is in my opinion; much too high for what I did.
2. The Staff member who Banned me had not even warned me to stop.
3. The Supposed "Disrespect" was me simply making a poor excuse of a joke towards him.
4. I was the only one out of a bunch who was banned, which I find to be favoritism.

If I did break rules, I am sorry. But I just felt since nothing was going on, there wouldn't be much harm. The other players seemed to have no issue with it, hell they even had fun.

I at least want to get my ban shortened, if not removed completely. I'm genuinely upset that I was removed from the server, I love playing on it. Yes I tend to get unserious, but do I think that warrants such a cruel and harsh punishment? No, not at all.

Regardless, thankyou for reading my Thread.


~Pumpkin
 

Sergeant Doggo

New Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2017
Messages
21
Points
3
Age
32
Location
United States of America
+1 I believe you should be unbanned as this is just wrong to only punish you and a warn or a kick hell even a warning for arrest is all viable for minging. You should not have been banned for that long first you should be warned then arrested if you continue you should be kicked if you continue after that you should be banned for a day or two.
 

Feds

Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2017
Messages
189
Points
18
Age
34
+1 but look at it as a lesson you need to take these types of conversations to discord or another voice chat and from what it seems you guys were trying to be behind a wall just so that they could here what your saying but you can oh we're in a another room you can't technically hear us. Take it to discord or the lounge.
 

TJR | Goose

Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2017
Messages
38
Points
8
Age
23
Location
United States of America
+1 but look at it as a lesson you need to take these types of conversations to discord or another voice chat and from what it seems you guys were trying to be behind a wall just so that they could here what your saying but you can oh we're in a another room you can't technically hear us. Take it to discord or the lounge.

You're right, It should of been reserved to a Discord.

Ill be ceasing use of my Microphone on the server if I'm unbanned, saving it for Discord, since it seems that I tend to get mingey if I have access to a mic on the server.
 

Sergeant Doggo

New Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2017
Messages
21
Points
3
Age
32
Location
United States of America
+1 but look at it as a lesson you need to take these types of conversations to discord or another voice chat and from what it seems you guys were trying to be behind a wall just so that they could here what your saying but you can oh we're in a another room you can't technically hear us. Take it to discord or the lounge.
the thing is that he was the only one to be punished this way
 

Vyvern

Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2017
Messages
56
Points
8
Age
25
+1 just make it 1 week ban
 
Last edited:

Sergeant Doggo

New Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2017
Messages
21
Points
3
Age
32
Location
United States of America
+1 because I understand the problem of waiting 5 years for an event and don't get shit to do, and the way Rome handled the situation was fucking bullshit because he didn't bring you into a sit or talk to you or even warn you like a staff member should. Plus I see people kill themselves for jokes all the time but where the fuck is staff because I literally type in staff chat that someone did that but jack shit happens. Then I have seen Rome disrespect troopers below him with "jokes" all the time but he doesn't get shit thrown at him.
Well said my guy
 

Firefox

New Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2017
Messages
21
Points
3
Age
22
+1 because I understand the problem of waiting 5 years for an event and don't get shit to do, and the way Rome handled the situation was fucking bullshit because he didn't bring you into a sit or talk to you or even warn you like a staff member should. Plus I see people kill themselves for jokes all the time but where the fuck is staff because I literally type in staff chat that someone did that but jack shit happens. Then I have seen Rome disrespect troopers below him with "jokes" all the time but he doesn't get shit thrown at him.
It's easy to miss something in staff chat, and as to your event thing if you haven't heard staff can't do events when there's training or tryouts or other RP related things.
 

Feds

Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2017
Messages
189
Points
18
Age
34
You're right, It should of been reserved to a Discord.

Ill be ceasing use of my Microphone on the server if I'm unbanned, saving it for Discord, since it seems that I tend to get mingey if I have access to a mic on the server.
Wait what don't cease use of your mic just learn when to talk and when not to which is something I also need to learn
 

Rome

New Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2017
Messages
19
Points
3
Location
Romania
Name of rule breaker: Goose, AKA Pumpkin

Reasons for his ban

- Minging
- FailRP
- In character, and out of character Disrespect.

Why he thinks the ban is false

- Favoritism
- Time too long
- Reasons are false
- Didn't warn him
- Didn't kick him (basically went to banning)

Basically why those are not valid

- I only banned him out of the group of people he was with because the other people were encouraged by him to be disrespectful, and a minge. For example, he was with Loki
Loki was fairly acting up as well, but Goose kept continuing after I said stop, and he was doing what a "bully" would do, get a bunch of people to gang up on me, so Loki being encouraged
by him, he decided to do the same as Goose, but after I banned Goose, they all walked away and it was over, hints the ban was necessary.

- The time is justified because I've been verbally warning him to stop for 5 - 6 hours, every time I ran into him or he came up to me, he'd do something small, for example, he said a 327th
trooper named Butterfly called me a faggot, which then I heard butterfly "thanks a lot for getting me in trouble for something I didn't do," then Goose laughs. It was obvious Goose was
trying to annoy me there. So I did the ban time because he was continuously disrespecting me all day, and minging. Keep in mind, I did warn him, and he has NO proof I didn't.

- The reasons are not false, he has no proof their false, and other Staff Members know he does Minge, he was literally banned for 1 - 2 weeks for minging during an event.

- I did not use the command to warn him, which was my mistake, and I will take any punishment for not doing that, but I did verbally warn him throughout the day to stop.

- I didn't kick him because every time I told him to stop, he would. I finally just went to a ban though because he continued all day, and I was finally done with the situation.
He knew what he was doing and it was time for him to stop.

NOTE: He has no proof that the ban was false, and I can bet my Staff Position on that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top